Checklist
A homeowners insurance renewal checklist before you pay.
Last updated June 4, 2026. Use this checklist to review the renewal notice, declarations page, and quote options without getting pulled into a price-only decision.
Record the core numbers
Write down the old annual premium, new annual premium, renewal date, and policy term. Then calculate the dollar increase and percentage increase.
RateReceipt focuses on annual numbers because they are easier to compare across homeowners and do not mix in mortgage escrow adjustments.
- Old annual premium
- New annual premium
- Dollar change
- Percentage change
- Renewal month and effective date
Compare limits and deductibles
Check whether Coverage A, other structures, personal property, loss of use, liability, and medical payments changed. Then compare deductibles line by line.
Separate deductibles are easy to miss. Wind, hail, hurricane, named-storm, wildfire, and water deductibles can change the real cost of a claim.
Confirm discounts and documents
Some discounts require updated proof. Roof age, monitored alarm, water shutoff, mitigation, claim-free, bundle, and new-home discounts may need documentation or may have expired.
Ask the insurer to list removed discounts. A short discount review can sometimes reduce a renewal without changing coverage.
Decide what kind of action is needed
A small increase may only require a discount review. A large increase, nonrenewal, new deductible, or coverage restriction deserves a deeper comparison and possibly official state resources.
Use the renewal as a decision point, not a panic point. The goal is to understand the change before you decide.
Common questions
What is the most important renewal item?
The annual premium matters, but deductible and coverage changes can matter just as much.
How many quotes should I compare?
Two or three comparable quotes are often enough to see whether the renewal is unusual, as long as the coverage assumptions match.
Should I upload my renewal to a website?
RateReceipt does not ask for documents. If another service requests uploads, review its privacy policy before sharing policy pages.